Another Slow Week
It was a slow news week for administrative law at the D.C. Circuit. And I’ve been equally slow getting this post up.
The court issued one opinion, in Abramowitz v. Lake, addressing Congress’s power to insulate an inferior officer from presidential removal—in this case, the head of Voice of America. Voice of America is one of six federally funded news broadcasters overseen by the U.S. Agency for Global Media. The Agency, which is broadly responsible for ensuring that news broadcasts reach regions of the world with the lowest levels of press freedom, is headed by a Chief Executive Officer appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate. That CEO supervises all broadcasting activities and logistical needs of the Agency. But much of the Agency’s agenda is set by a separate independent agency, the seven-member International Broadcasting Advisory Board. By statute, the Board directly oversees the Agency’s CEO and controls the hiring and firing of all six heads of the news broadcasters that fall within the Agency’s ambit. One of those heads is Michael Abramowitz, who was unanimously appointed by the Board to lead Voice of America in 2024.
When President Trump assumed office in January 2025, he gutted the Board and issued an executive order directing the Agency to eliminate “to the maximum extent consistent with applicable law” all non-statutory components and functions. In accordance with that order and following several rounds of injunctive litigation, the Agency and its acting leadership removed Abramowitz as head of Voice of America. Abramowitz sued, arguing that the Agency and its acting leadership violated the APA and acted ultra vires by attempting to remove him without approval of the Board. The district court permanently enjoined the Agency from removing Abramowitz without the Board’s approval, and the Agency appealed.
After confirming the district court’s jurisdiction, a unanimous panel affirmed the injunction. The D.C. Circuit rejected the Agency’s argument that requiring Board approval for removals violates Article II. Abramowitz, the court wrote, is “undisputedly an inferior officer” and thus power over his removal could be constitutionally vested by Congress in the Board. Relying on Free Enterprise Fund v. Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, the court okayed agency structures whereby inferior officers are insulated from presidential removal because removal authority is vested in the hands of an agency head that the President can remove at-will. The practical effect of this ruling, as others have observed, is that President Trump cannot currently remove Abramowitz unless and until he appoints (and the Senate confirms) a quorum of the Board. As a result, it seems likely that the Administration will seek further review.
In other news, the Supreme Court agreed to hear Mullin v. RAICES, a challenge to President Trump’s Proclamation 10888 shutting down all asylum at the southern border. The D.C. Circuit previously rejected the Proclamation as unlawful under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA). The Supreme Court granted cert on two questions: whether the Proclamation and DHS’s guidance implementing it violate the INA, and whether 8 U.S.C. § 1252(f)(1) barred the district court from granting classwide relief.
Alexis J. Abboud is a Harry A. Bigelow Teaching Fellow and Lecturer in Law at the University of Chicago. Her research lies at the intersection of contract, administrative, and constitutional law.

