Like all who follow admin law or the D.C. Circuit to any degree, my colleagues here at D.C. Circuit Review have been keeping track of decisions illustrating the Circuit’s emerging approach to Loper Bright. Last week offers two more examples to consider, which were also the only two admin law decisions from the week, and […]
One of my go-to resources for trying to stay abreast of developments in constitutional law is the National Constitution Center and especially its podcast, We, the People. Under the inspired and able direction of Jeff Rosen, its president and CEO (and former D. C. Circuit clerk), the Center consistently produces excellent materials on the history […]
The D.C. Circuit issued two decisions last week. Both offer early examples of what administrative deference and respect looks like now that courts no longer defer to agency interpretations of statutes under Chevron. In Pacific Gas & Electric Company v. FERC, the Court once again considered PG&E’s obligations to distribute (“wheel”) its competitor’s energy to […]
The D.C. Circuit’s internal August 15 deadline for circulating opinions has come and gone, and the pace of opinions has started to slow. The court issued six opinions last week, only four of which involve administrative law. And it was a mixed bag for the agencies, as the court vacated multiple agency actions and regulations. […]
As August rolls on, the D.C. Circuit released five published opinions in administrative law cases last week. One vacated a do-over by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, two addressed standing, one addressed mootness, and one applied the Freedom of Information Act. FERC In City of Port Isabel v. FERC, the court vacated FERC’s reauthorization of two […]
The D.C. Circuit published eight opinions this week, including two on the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (here and here), one on standing to appeal a denial of a motion for class certification, another on the constitutionality of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (spoiler alert: the facial challenges failed), and one on what I trust is […]
As Judge Griffith noted, it’s peak opinion-issuing season at the D.C. Circuit. The court issued 15 opinions last week, about 10 of which fall into the “admin law” category. So the recaps will necessarily be brief! Perhaps the most noteworthy decision came in Amazon Services LLC v. U.S. Dep’t of Agriculture, No. 22-1052, where the […]
In the first week of July, the D.C. Circuit issued five administrative-law opinions. First, in Evergreen Shipping Agency (America) Corp. v. Federal Maritime Commission, the court vacated an order that involved late fees for borrowed shipping containers. In April 2020, an ocean carrier (Evergreen) gave several loaded shipping containers to a trucking company (TCW) at […]
An internal rule of the D.C. Circuit encourages the circulation among the panel of all opinions for the previous term by August 15 of each year. Which means that July and early August can be stressful times in chambers. They certainly were in mine because, try as I might, I never mastered the skill of […]
The D.C. Circuit issued ten opinions last week, nine of which involved administrative law. We have three FERC opinions, two NLRB opinions, and one each about FCC, FDA, FEC, and DHS. Buckle your seatbelts, it’s going to be a long post. Beginning with the FERC cases: In Shell Energy North America v. FERC, the D.C. […]
While some other things were happening last week in administrative law, the D.C. Circuit decided four cases of note. The first one involved a (Chevron-free) disagreement over the meaning of the Mining Law of 1872. In Earthworks v. Department of the Interior, a divided panel affirmed the entry of summary judgment for the Interior Department in a […]
The D.C. Circuit released eight opinions last week, including one under seal. The subjects ranged widely and included contract law, personal jurisdiction, insurance law, a defamation action, and the Speech or Debate Clause. In Husky Marketing and Supply Company v. FERC, the D.C. Circuit denied petitions for review of FERC orders approving rates for crude-oil […]
Only two true admin law opinions among the D.C. Circuit’s six decisions last week, both involving FERC. In the first FERC case, N.Y. State Public Service Comm’n v. FERC, No. 23-1192, the agency survived a challenge to a flip-flop in agency positions by a 2-1 vote. The majority opinion, written by Judge Randolph, noted that […]
My former colleague and good friend Judge David Tatel has been in the headlines of late with the release of his memoir, Vision: A Memoir of Blindness and Justice. The articles about the book that I have read have, predictably, focused on Judge Tatel’s criticism of the Roberts Court. See, e.g., Ann Marimow’s article in […]
In Absolute Healthcare v. NLRB, the D.C. Circuit granted a petition to review (in part) an NLRB order finding that an employer committed unfair labor practices and ordering various remedial measures. But to describe the decision in this way is to obscure a rather unusual feature of the case. Here is how Judge Walker, in a […]