Notice & Comment

Symposia

Notice & Comment

Centering Proportionality in the Administrative Procedure Act

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. In this era of the rapid change in administrative law—both at the Supreme Court and from the White House—I am grateful that Senator Schmitt has stepped up as a thought leader in the Senate […]

Notice & Comment

Congress after Loper Bright: Prioritize Modernization and Learning, by Dane Stangler, Michael Thorning, & J.D. Rackey

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. We agree with Sen. Eric Schmitt that “Congress must reclaim the habit of legislating.” While much of the senator’s report and commentary addresses the challenges posed by the administrative state, we hope he and […]

Notice & Comment

Congressional Review Act(ion) After Loper Bright, by Eric Wessan

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. The Congressional Review Act is a congressional eraser that wipes agency rules clean—and prevents their future reenactment. President Trump is wielding the Act more effectively than ever before, with a Republican trifecta in control […]

Notice & Comment

A Blueprint for Inaction and Gridlock, by Devon Ombres

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. The Post-Chevron Working Group Report reads less as a plan to improve Americans’ lives through streamlining agencies and achieving democratic accountability than as a broadside against the functionality of American governance that has risen […]

Notice & Comment

“Necessary” Discretion: A Primer for Non-Lawyers, by Kara McKenna Rollins

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. It has been nearly a decade since Justice Elena Kagan summarized the judicial interpretation zeitgeist by noting that “[w]e’re all textualists now.”[1] And while it may be that textualism is a predominate form of […]

Notice & Comment

Loper Bright as Evidence of Unlawful Regulations, by Eli Nachmany

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. Senator Eric Schmitt’s Post-Chevron Working Group Report is live. The document (and the lead-up to its publication) reflects a careful process of congressional engagement with a landmark decision of the Supreme Court—Loper Bright Enterprises […]

Notice & Comment

Who Speaks for the Senate?, by Beau J. Baumann

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. I have a certain obsession with Congress’s capacity for legal deliberation. I have tried to build out the promise of the ongoing renaissance in legislative constitutionalism.[i] In Resurrecting the Trinity of Legislative Constitutionalism, I […]

Notice & Comment

The Anti-Regulatory Movement’s Loper Bright Paradox, by Richard L. Revesz & Max Sarinsky

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. How should one think about Loper Bright? On its face, Loper Bright is a meaningful yet measured Supreme Court decision that requires agencies to act consistently with the best statutory readings. But for some, […]

Notice & Comment

State Farm and Making Deregulation Make Sense, by James Burnham

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. Chevron is now in the dustbin of history, and the Senate Working Group’s Report establishes a blueprint for what Congress should do next.  One of my top priorities as General Counsel of DOGE was […]

Notice & Comment

Foreword—The Post-Chevron Working Group Report in Action: Reclaiming the Constitution from the Administrative State, by Senator Eric Schmitt

This post introduces Notice & Comment’s symposium on the Senate Post-Chevron Working Group Report. For other posts in the series, click here. The Constitution never created, and the American people never voted for, an unelected fourth branch of government. Yet over the last century, a malignant administrative state has grown like kudzu over our constitutional […]

Notice & Comment

How Should the Government’s Automated Legal Guidance Evolve?: A Response, by Joshua D. Blank & Leigh Osofsky

This post concludes Notice & Comment’s symposium on Joshua D. Blank and Leigh Osofsky’s Automated Agencies: The Transformation of Government Guidance. For other posts in the series, click here. Thank you to the editors of JREG for organizing the wonderful symposium this week regarding our new book, Automated Agencies: The Transformation of Government Guidance, and thank you to […]

Notice & Comment

The Promise and Pitfalls of Point-and-Click Government, by Kristin Hickman

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on Joshua D. Blank and Leigh Osofsky’s Automated Agencies: The Transformation of Government Guidance. For other posts in the series, click here. We live in a computerized, point-and-click world. Increasingly, this means that our interactions with the government also are reduced to pointing and clicking at the computer. In […]

Notice & Comment

Disclaimers, by Emily Cauble

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on Joshua D. Blank and Leigh Osofsky’s Automated Agencies: The Transformation of Government Guidance. For other posts in the series, click here. In Automated Agencies, Professors Blank and Osofsky offer “the definitive account of how automation is transforming government explanations of law to the public,” as the book’s description […]

Notice & Comment

Democratizing to Protect Against Government “Slop,” by Clint Wallace

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on Joshua D. Blank and Leigh Osofsky’s Automated Agencies: The Transformation of Government Guidance. For other posts in the series, click here. It is a pleasure to participate in this symposium on Josh Blank’s and Leigh Osofsky’s excellent new book, Automated Agencies. Their work intersects in significant and interesting […]

Notice & Comment

The Automated Legal Guidance Effect, by Sarah B. Lawsky

This post is part of Notice & Comment’s symposium on Joshua D. Blank and Leigh Osofsky’s Automated Agencies: The Transformation of Government Guidance. For other posts in the series, click here. Automated Agencies: The Transformation of Government Guidance, by Joshua D. Blank and Leigh Osofsky, is part of the authors’ larger study of informal legal guidance, such as […]