Notice & Comment

Notice & Comment

Notice & Comment

DACA Through the Critical Systems Thinking (CST) Lens: Unpacking Racialization in Administrative Law, by Raquel Muñiz

In June 2020, the Supreme Court ruled on the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) case, finding that the Trump administration was arbitrary and capricious in its rescission of the policy in violation of a core administrative law principle. According to the Court, the administration failed to consider the reliance interests of DACA recipients in its […]

Notice & Comment

Lessons on Race and Place-Based Participation from Environmental Justice and Geography, by Sonya Ziaja

In America, to be agnostic about place is likely being agnostic about race. As scholars grapple with racism in Administrative Law, it is important to consider place-based scholarship from the perspectives of Environmental Justice (EJ) and Geography. Both provide important insights into how administrative agencies can be instruments of strategic-structural racism and how administrative law can facilitate […]

Notice & Comment

The Minor Questions Doctrine

I’m pleased to report that the University of Pennsylvania Law Review has agreed to publish my latest article: The Minor Questions Doctrine. Here’s the abstract: Few aspects of administrative law are as controversial as the major questions doctrine—the exception to Chevron deference that bars courts from deferring to an agency’s otherwise reasonable interpretation of an […]

Notice & Comment

The Origination Clause and Why House Democrats May Have Standing to Challenge the Recent Executive Order on Payroll Taxes

With COVID-19 cases still common throughout the United States and unemployment around 10 percent, many Americans are in a dire economic situation. As the COVID-19 economic stimulus recently expired, and President Trump and Congress have been unable to reach any agreement on an extension, President Trump unilaterally issued four executive orders for economic relief. Many […]

Notice & Comment

Gundy, Nondelegation, and Criminal Law

The nondelegation doctrine says that a statute can give rulemaking power to an agency so long as the statute contains an intelligible principle directing how that power must be used. For years, the doctrine was a joke.  Courts routinely upheld laws with the slimmest of intelligible principles, and sometimes they even read intelligible principles into […]

Notice & Comment

The Payroll Tax Relief Program Won’t Work

Through a White House memorandum, President Trump directed the Treasury Department to exercise the authority conferred by Section 7508A. Under that statute, the Treasury may extend various otherwise strict deadlines under the tax code, including those for the payment of taxes. The White House memorandum contemplates that the Treasury will use Section 7508A to extend […]

Notice & Comment

Fintech, Regulatory Restraint, and 10 Years of Dodd-Frank, by David Zaring

Dodd-Frank turned 10 years old recently, an occasion for retrospectives about what the statute has accomplished as implemented, and where it has been found wanting. The retrospectives have established, if we did not already know it, that the meaning of Dodd-Frank was not fixed in stone by Congress in July, 2010, but, rather, can only […]